All series/Garage Sale Mysteries

Garage Sale Mysteries

Antiques dealer Jennifer Shannon spots evidence in the second-hand objects other people overlook.

16 films · 2013–2020 · Mystery

Start with the first film

Movies in viewing order

Begin with Garage Sale Mystery and follow the sequence below. Individual investigations have their own starting problem, so you can choose a later case by its antique or setting, but the first film introduces Jennifer and Dani. All That Glitters and The Deadly Room belong before The Wedding Dress.

Your viewing checklist

Saved films and watched progress stay separate in this browser.
  1. 01Garage Sale Mystery poster

    Garage Sale Mystery

    Jennifer finds a friend dead after meeting her at a garage sale. What police regard as an accident makes Jennifer question whether a pattern of break-ins points to something more deliberate.

    Film source
  2. 02Garage Sale Mystery: All That Glitters poster

    Garage Sale Mystery: All That Glitters

    Jennifer buys a storage unit at auction, then the facility owner is murdered. Her purchases and position as a witness draw her into the investigation.

    Film source
  3. 03Garage Sale Mystery: The Deadly Room poster

    Garage Sale Mystery: The Deadly Room

    A friend dies after trying to disprove a house's deadly reputation. Jennifer looks for evidence behind the supposed curse.

    Film source
  4. 04Garage Sale Mystery: The Wedding Dress poster

    Garage Sale Mystery: The Wedding Dress

    An old wedding dress prompts Jennifer to investigate a groom's disappearance. The object sends her into a cold case, rather than a death that has just disrupted the shop's daily business.

    Film source
  5. 05Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent poster

    Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent

    An old college friend becomes the main suspect in a murder. Jennifer's interest in the case is personal, as she tries to work out whether the evidence against someone she knows tells the whole story.

    Film source
  6. 06Garage Sale Mystery: The Novel Murders poster

    Garage Sale Mystery: The Novel Murders

    Jennifer recognises details from a mystery novel at a murder scene. Her investigation depends on reading those apparent references correctly, making this a case for viewers who like literary clues.

    Film source
  7. 07Garage Sale Mystery: The Art of Murder poster

    Garage Sale Mystery: The Art of Murder

    Preparations for a charity garage sale lead Jennifer to a body in a nearby attic. Her work organising the sale becomes an investigation that relies on the same attention to detail she brings to antiques.

    Film source
  8. 08Garage Sale Mystery: The Beach Murder poster

    Garage Sale Mystery: The Beach Murder

    A widow asks Jennifer to question an apparent drowning after her husband is found on an isolated beach. His experience in the water gives the request a specific reason for doubt.

    Film source
  9. 09Garage Sale Mystery: Murder by Text poster

    Garage Sale Mystery: Murder by Text

    A bass player's death interrupts preparations for a country singer's tour. Jennifer's investigation moves into the band's working circle, where the events before the scheduled performances matter to the case.

    Film source
  10. 10Garage Sale Mystery: Murder Most Medieval poster

    Garage Sale Mystery: Murder Most Medieval

    A suit of armour turns out to contain a history professor's body. Jennifer's latest purchase puts her in contact with an academic circle and makes a collector's object the start of a murder inquiry.

    Film source
  11. 11Garage Sale Mystery: A Case of Murder poster

    Garage Sale Mystery: A Case of Murder

    Jennifer buys a reel-to-reel recorder and hears a man pleading for his life on its tape. Instead of a visual mark on an antique, this case begins with recorded sound.

    Film source
  12. 12Garage Sale Mysteries: The Pandora's Box Murders poster

    Garage Sale Mysteries: The Pandora's Box Murders

    A woman asks Jennifer to examine a puzzle box left by her mother-in-law. The box leads Jennifer into a family's history, with an object's concealed contents at the centre of her questions.

    Film source
  13. 13Garage Sale Mystery: The Mask Murder poster

    Garage Sale Mystery: The Mask Murder

    Buying stock at a storage auction leads Jennifer to a young woman's body in another locker. The business of sorting other people's abandoned belongings brings her into a very current investigation.

    Film source
  14. 14Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder poster

    Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder

    An antique camera from a photography enthusiast's estate attracts Jennifer's attention. This case gives photographs a role in her investigation, so the purchase offers more than the value of the camera itself.

    Film source
  15. 15Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder In D Minor poster

    Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder In D Minor

    Jennifer wins a vintage player piano at an estate auction. Questions about its late owner's history turn an expensive acquisition into a reason to investigate the man who once possessed it.

    Film source
  16. 16Garage Sale Mysteries: Searched & Seized poster

    Garage Sale Mysteries: Searched & Seized

    Jennifer bids at a police auction for another antiques dealer. His death leads her towards counterfeiting and organised crime.

    Film source

About the series

Jennifer Shannon buys stock for her consignment shop with business partner Dani, but an unusual purchase often carries a more troubling history. Lori Loughlin leads a series built around objects, customers and a recurring family circle, with Sarah Strange as Dani. The sequence below includes all 16 earlier films on Hallmark's franchise list. The announced September 19 film appears separately so it cannot be mistaken for one already released.

What to expect

The shop brings Jennifer into contact with owners, collectors and people clearing out homes. A dress, recording or camera can become the route into a case. Jennifer's family and Dani give the films a continuing cast around those investigations. Choose this series for an amateur sleuth whose day job explains how she keeps finding clues.

The people who bring it to life

Lori Loughlin

Jennifer Shannon

Lori Loughlin

An antiques dealer and amateur investigator who follows the histories attached to her purchases.

Sarah Strange

Dani

Sarah Strange

Jennifer's business partner at the consignment shop, where the buying and sorting continue around the cases.

Steve Bacic

Jason Shannon

Steve Bacic

Jennifer's husband in the continuing films. Steve Bacic follows the first film's portrayal by Rick Ravanello.

Kevin O'Grady

Frank Lynwood

Kevin O'Grady

The detective Jennifer works with as her finds become evidence in police investigations.

Eva Bourne

Hannah Shannon

Eva Bourne

Jennifer and Jason's daughter, part of the family life that continues between investigations.

Connor Stanhope

Logan Shannon

Connor Stanhope

Jennifer and Jason's son, played by Connor Stanhope in the continuing run.

More cast and guest appearances 14

Inside the series

The object is a useful way to choose a case

The Wedding Dress follows a missing groom, A Case of Murder starts with a recording, and Picture a Murder uses a camera. If you are returning to the series, those objects distinguish the cases more clearly than their similar titles.

Pandora's Box is not an extra film

Hallmark calls the film The Pandora's Box Murders. Some catalogue listings shorten it to Pandora's Box. This guide treats those as the same entry, in the place before The Mask Murder.

A few more answers

How many Garage Sale Mysteries films are released?

Hallmark's franchise list contains 16 released films as of September 13, 2026. All That Glitters, The Deadly Room and Searched & Seized are included in the sequence. The announced Murder Takes the Stage is listed separately.

Is Murder Takes the Stage out yet?

As checked on September 13, 2026, Hallmark advertises its premiere for September 19. It is shown as an announcement, outside the released-film sequence.

Do I need to watch every earlier case?

Release order is best for meeting the recurring cast. The individual premises also let you choose a case about an object or setting that interests you, without this guide revealing its solution.

Sources & guide notes

Sources checked 13 September 2026. The film count follows the sequence above. Viewing options depend on your country.

Premiere date notes

Garage Sale Mystery. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mystery: The Wedding Dress. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mystery: Guilty Until Proven Innocent. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mystery: The Novel Murders. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mystery: The Art of Murder. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mystery: The Beach Murder. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mystery: Murder by Text. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mystery: Murder Most Medieval. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mystery: A Case of Murder. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mysteries: The Pandora's Box Murders. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mystery: The Mask Murder. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mysteries: Picture a Murder. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.

Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder In D Minor. Exact premiere date unconfirmed. The listed year comes from the catalogue.