The Best Hallmark Romance Movies, Ranked

Ranked by IMDb average rating among Hallmark romance titles in our database, highest first.

1. 1
   

   The Christmas Wishing Tree

   2017 · 120 min★ 8.4

   Topping the list at 8.4, this is essentially a "When Calls the Heart" Christmas special. Erin Krakow's Elizabeth waits out the holiday in frontier Hope Valley while her fiance Jack serves up north as a Mountie, and the town launches a wishing tree where people tie up requests for other people, never themselves. It's warm, faith-driven, and built for fans of the show. The romance is the gentle, longing kind, and the deep ensemble cast gives it real heft. If you love the series, this is comfort viewing of the highest order.

2. 2
   

   New Year's Wish

   2015 · 85 min★ 8.4

   Another 8.4, and another Hope Valley favorite. This "When Calls the Heart" New Year's special juggles a jealousy scare between Jack and Elizabeth, an elaborate fib from Rosemary and Lee, and a few town secrets working their way to the surface. Erin Krakow and a stacked franchise cast lead. The pleasure is purely in spending time with characters you already love as they ring in a new year. It's episodic and ensemble-driven rather than one central romance, so it lands best if you're already invested in the show.

3. 3
   

   Signed, Sealed, Delivered: The Vows We Have Made

   2021 · 86 min★ 8.1

   An 8.1, and a milestone for "Signed, Sealed, Delivered" fans: Shane and Oliver are finally preparing for their wedding, while helping a young boy with leukemia reunite with a long-lost friend and Rita and Norman work toward starting a family. Eric Mabius and Kristin Booth lead the beloved quartet. It's the payoff to a romance fans followed for years, wrapped in the show's gentle, faith-tinged warmth. If you've watched the series, this is the swoony, satisfying one. Newcomers should start earlier in the saga.

4. 4
   

   When Calls the Heart

   2014 · 43 min★ 7.9

   The 7.9-rated pilot of "When Calls the Heart," and with nearly 16,000 votes, the most-watched title on this whole list. Erin Krakow's Elizabeth, a wealthy young schoolteacher, leaves the city to teach in a rough frontier coal town and crosses paths with Mountie Jack Thornton. This is the origin of the entire Hope Valley universe and the slow-burn romance fans built a fandom around. The period setting and the fish-out-of-water setup give it real charm. Start here if you want to understand why this franchise has such a devoted following.

5. 5
   

   Guiding Emily

   2023 · 84 min★ 7.8

   A 7.8, and a lovely, more dramatic pick. Sarah Drew plays Emily, a high-achiever rebuilding her life after a rock-climbing accident leaves her blind, right as a spirited puppy named Garth works through his guide-dog training. Antonio Cupo plays the friend who quietly becomes more. It's really a story about independence and genuine partnership, with the romance growing alongside Emily's hard-won autonomy. Garth even gets his own inner monologue, which is a charming touch. Watch it for the heart and a strong central performance. A romance with real substance under it.

6. 6
   

   Signed, Sealed, Delivered: From the Heart

   2016 · 84 min★ 7.7

   A 7.7. A Valentine's Day case for the POstables: a singed letter from a long-ago mailbox explosion holds a shocking confession, and the team has to track down both sender and recipient. The full "Signed, Sealed, Delivered" quartet leads, with Norman chasing down a possibly historic Valentine on the side. It blends a tender mystery with the team's own romantic milestones. More gentle and character-driven than swoony, and a real treat for series fans. The lost-letter-as-love-story structure is the show at its warmest.

7. 7
   

   Signed, Sealed, Delivered: Home Again

   2017 · 87 min★ 7.7

   A 7.7. The POstables uncover a long-lost mailbag and a valuable porcelain vase mailed by three young sisters, then race to return it in time to save the family farm, only to learn the artifact has a fraught history. Eric Mabius and the full team lead, with Barry Bostwick and Kim Delaney guesting. The romance threads hum quietly beneath a meaty case about doing what's right versus doing what's legal. A multi-generational, emotionally satisfying entry. Watch it for the team's chemistry and a story with more moral weight than most.

8. 8
   

   My Christmas Family Tree

   2021 · 84 min★ 7.6

   A 7.6. Aimee Teegarden plays Vanessa, a social worker raised in foster care who takes a DNA test, discovers a family she never knew existed, and spends Christmas with them, growing close to a charming family friend named Kris. Andrew W. Walker co-stars. The romance is sweet and unhurried, set against a found-family story with a soft holiday glow. A gentle, heartfelt watch about belonging and second chances. Easy to love and easy to recommend.

9. 9
   

   Three Wise Men and a Baby

   2022 · 84 min★ 7.5

   A 7.5, and a rare male-led Hallmark romance. Paul Campbell, Tyler Hynes, and Andrew W. Walker play three estranged brothers stuck caring for a baby left at a fire station just before Christmas. The trio's chemistry is the engine, and the romance threads through the chaos of diapers, feedings, and a competitive holiday decorating contest. With over 4,000 votes, fans clearly adore it. Watch it for the comedy and the brotherly heart as much as the love story. A genuine crowd-pleaser.

10. 10
    

    November Christmas

    2010 · 96 min★ 7.5

    A 7.5, and one of the heavier entries on the list. A seriously ill young girl inspires her small town to "move up the clock" and celebrate the holidays early, with Sam Elliott and John Corbett anchoring a strong cast. The romance is a quieter strand inside what's really a community drama about hope and grief. The tone is serious rather than cozy, so come for emotional weight, not light flirtation. Beautifully acted and genuinely affecting. A pick for anyone who wants their Hallmark with real depth.

11. 11
    

    Silent Night

    2002 · 100 min★ 7.5

    A 7.5, and a striking outlier. Linda Hamilton plays a German mother who brokers a fragile Christmas Eve truce between American and German soldiers sheltering in her cabin during the Battle of the Bulge. There's actual combat here, which is bold for the brand. The "romance" is really about shared humanity rather than coupling, so set your expectations accordingly. Serious, restrained, and surprisingly moving. Watch it as a small-scale wartime drama with a Hallmark heart, not a typical love story. A genuine departure.

12. 12
    

    Five More Minutes

    2021 · 83 min★ 7.5

    A 7.5. Nikki DeLoach plays Clara, home to help run her late grandfather's Christmas shop while reconnecting with high school sweetheart Logan. David Haydn-Jones co-stars. The romance is a tender second-chance arc, deepened by grief and a soft supernatural layer involving her grandfather's old journal and a mysterious new employee. It earns its emotion honestly. Watch it for the quiet ache under the holiday warmth and two leads with easy chemistry. A lovely choice if you like your romance with a lump in the throat.

13. 13
    

    Time for Him to Come Home for Christmas

    2022 · 84 min★ 7.4

    A 7.4, with over 2,000 votes. Holland Roden plays a journalist who gets a heartfelt wrong-number voicemail and sets out to find who it was meant for, dragging her estranged best friend, played by Tyler Hynes, along for the search. It's part light mystery, part second-chance romance, all of it unfolding over four days before Christmas. The detective hook gives the romance more drive than usual, and Hynes is reliably charming. Watch it for the slow rekindling between the leads and a satisfying chase. A well-paced fan favorite.

14. 14
    

    Ghosts of Christmas Always

    2022 · 84 min★ 7.4

    A 7.4. Kim Matula plays Katherine, the Ghost of Christmas Present, assigned to a man who's already brimming with holiday spirit and, strangely, the only mortal who remembers her. Ian Harding co-stars. The romance crosses the living-and-dead line, which makes it one of the more unusual love stories here. High-concept and a touch melancholy, with a clever "A Christmas Carol" spin. Watch it for the inventive premise and the wistful chemistry between ghost and mortal. Charming and a little strange in the best way.

15. 15
    

    A Dog Named Christmas

    2009 · 95 min★ 7.4

    A 7.4, and a quieter, more dramatic film. Noel Fisher plays Todd, a young man with a developmental disability who rallies his rural Kansas town behind an "Adopt-A-Dog for Christmas" program, while Bruce Greenwood plays his guarded father, carrying old wounds. The emphasis is on empathy and healing far more than romance, so adjust expectations going in. The dog story gives it heart without tipping into saccharine. Watch it for the family drama and the gentle, animal-loving warmth. A tender pick that earns its emotion.

16. 16
    

    To All a Good Night

    2023 · 90 min★ 7.4

    A 7.4. Kimberley Sustad plays Ceci, a small-town photographer who saves a mysterious motorcyclist, played by Mark Ghanime, after a crash, then grows wary when she learns he may be eyeing her family's land. The romance is a sweet will-they-won't-they wrapped inside a healing-after-loss story, with a scene-stealing thieving dog for comic relief. Well-cast and warm. Watch it for the easy chemistry and the light mystery folded into the love story. A solid, satisfying comfort watch.

17. 17
    

    Unexpected Grace

    2023 · 84 min★ 7.4

    A 7.4. A young girl named Grace finds a child's note in a long-lost balloon, writes back, and unknowingly strikes up a correspondence with a grieving mother, played by Erica Durance, just as Grace's father, played by Michael Rady, begins falling for that same woman. It's a tender story about coincidence, grief, and finding family in unexpected places, with the romance growing straight out of shared loss. Watch it for the heartfelt premise and the gentle emotional payoff. Quietly affecting and well-acted.

18. 18
    

    Love Comes Softly

    2003 · 88 min★ 7.3

    A 7.3, with over 7,000 votes, and the film that launched the "Love Comes Softly" saga. A young Katherine Heigl plays Marty, widowed on the frontier and offered a marriage of convenience by a grieving widower with a young daughter. This is the original slow-burn, a love that grows quietly through one hard winter, rooted in grief and faith. The period setting is gorgeous, and the romance is patient and earned. Watch it for old-fashioned, prairie-set tenderness. A foundational title for fans of Hallmark's historical romances.

19. 19
    

    The Most Wonderful Time of the Year

    2008 · 88 min★ 7.3

    A 7.3, with over 5,000 votes. Henry Winkler plays a meddling uncle who all but drags a charming drifter, played by Warren Christie, home to set up his uptight single-mom niece, played by Brooke Burns. The romance is breezy and a little comedic, built on spontaneity versus control, with Winkler plainly having a ball. Watch it for the easy charm and the family meddling that keeps shoving the couple together. A lighter, very rewatchable entry. Comfort food with a great supporting turn.

20. 20
    

    The Wedding Veil

    2022 · 84 min★ 7.3

    A 7.3, with over 2,600 votes, and the start of the "Wedding Veil" trilogy. Lacey Chabert plays Avery, one of three college friends who buy an antique veil said to bring its bearer true love. She meets a philanthropist named Peter, played by Kevin McGarry, and a misunderstanding complicates things before they end up collaborating on a museum gala. The romance is classic Chabert: warm, smart, and easy to root for. Watch it for the leads, the female friendship at its core, and the gentle fate-versus-coincidence question. A charming franchise opener.

21. 21
    

    The Wedding Veil Legacy

    2022 · 84 min★ 7.3

    The third Wedding Veil film closes out the trilogy's main romance. Alison Sweeney plays Tracy, a guarded New York auction-house director who inherits the legendary matchmaking veil right as her long relationship ends, then crosses paths with Victor Webster's chef Nick while trying to save a historic draft of The New Colossus. The pleasure is watching a self-protective woman let her guard down. At 7.3 it is a glossy, big-city romance with a fated twist. Watch it for Sweeney and Webster's easy heat, ideally after the first two films in the set.

22. 22
    

    Hanukkah on Rye

    2022 · 85 min★ 7.3

    Yael Grobglas and Jeremy Jordan play Molly and Jacob, who fall for each other fast at a singles event only to discover they run rival family delicatessens. The deli-war-meets-Hanukkah hook is a fresh change of pace for the brand, with Lisa Loeb in the cast and a warm, latke-scented sense of place. At 7.3 it is a charming enemies-adjacent romance with real banter. Watch it for the competing-businesses tension, the Hanukkah setting that Hallmark rarely centers, and two leads who genuinely spark off each other.

23. 23
    

    A Reason for the Season

    2024 · 84 min★ 7.3

    Taylor Cole plays Evie, a billionaire heiress sent back to the small town where she was born and tasked with secretly rewarding the four strangers who saved her life the night she arrived, or she forfeits her trust fund. Kevin McGarry is the local lawyer who helps her track them down without blowing her cover. It is an anonymous-giving romance with a likable mission structure and a Christmas Eve deadline. At 7.3 it is a strong recent entry. Watch it for the gift-giving warmth and McGarry's easy charm.

24. 24
    

    The Wedding Veil Journey

    2023 · 84 min★ 7.3

    The second Wedding Veil sequel sends the central couple on a long-delayed honeymoon to Greece that promptly goes off the rails. Alison Sweeney and Victor Webster play workaholics Tracy and Nick, stranded at a remote island inn where Nick quietly rescues the kitchen and Tracy bonds with a gifted local orphan. The change of scenery to a sun-drenched Greek island sets it apart from the snowbound entries. At 7.3 it is a warm, scenic romance about a married couple deciding what comes next. Watch it for the travel-postcard backdrop and the established chemistry.

25. 25
    

    A Mrs. Miracle Christmas

    2021 · 84 min★ 7.3

    Caroline Rhea plays Gloria Merkel, a magical caregiver who arrives to help a couple grieving a failed adoption while she looks after a widowed grandmother. It is gentle and a little melancholy, handling infertility and loss more openly than most films in this lane. The supernatural-nanny conceit smooths everyone's troubles with a knowing smile. At 7.3 it is a warm one for viewers who like a faith-and-healing throughline. Watch it for Rhea's easy comic timing, the soft miracles, and a romance that grows out of real grief rather than around it.

26. 26
    

    Color My World with Love

    2022 · 84 min★ 7.3

    A rare and genuinely moving entry: Erica Durance plays Emma, an overprotective mother whose daughter Kendall, played by Malaika Jackson, gets engaged to Brad, played by David DeSanctis, with both leads being actors with Down syndrome. As Emma frets over Kendall's independence, she falls for Brad's brother Nic, played by Benjamin Ayres. The dual romance, one young and one middle-aged, is handled with unusual warmth. At 7.3 it is a standout for representation alone. Watch it for a love story Hallmark almost never tells, told with real tenderness.

27. 27
    

    Signed, Sealed, Delivered: A Tale of Three Letters

    2024★ 7.3

    The Postables return in a 2024 case built around three letters pulled from a years-old mailbox explosion, each delivery hitting the team personally. Eric Mabius, Kristin Booth, Crystal Lowe, and Geoff Gustafson are the whole draw, with the newly married Oliver and Shane adjusting to wedded life while Norman and Rita pursue adoption. At 7.3 it is gentle, faith-tinged comfort for the faithful. Newcomers should start earlier in the saga. Watch it for the postal-detective warmth and a romance that has clearly been earned across many films.

28. 28
    

    The Nine Lives of Christmas

    2014 · 86 min★ 7.2

    Brandon Routh plays Zachary, a commitment-phobic firefighter whose tidy single life gets upended when a stray cat adopts him and nudges him toward Kimberley Sustad's veterinary student. The cat does most of the matchmaking, which is as charming as it sounds. It is a low-stakes, deeply cozy opposites-and-pets romance with a house-renovation backdrop. At 7.2 with nearly 5,000 votes, it is a much-loved standby. Watch it for the animal antics and two leads who are very easy to spend 86 minutes with.

29. 29
    

    On the 12th Date of Christmas

    2020 · 84 min★ 7.2

    Two rival game designers, Mallory Jansen and Tyler Hynes, are forced to build a citywide Christmas scavenger hunt together while competing for the same promotion. The conceit lets them tour romantic Chicago spots as they fall for each other, which is a tidy bit of engineering. It is a workplace-rivals-to-lovers setup with playful energy, and Hynes is reliably good in it. At 7.2 with over 2,800 votes, fans rate it well. A nice one if you like a little gamesmanship and a brisk, big-city holiday backdrop with your romance.

30. 30
    

    A Dickens of a Holiday!

    2021 · 84 min★ 7.2

    Brooke D'Orsay plays Cassie, a small-town director staging the centennial production of A Christmas Carol who recruits hometown action star Jake, played by Kristoffer Polaha, after her lead loses his voice. The high school spark between director and leading man reignites as he tries to prove he has dramatic range. At 7.2 it is a breezy showbiz-meets-small-town romance with a fun play-within-the-movie. Watch it for Polaha's comic charm, the second-chance-with-the-one-who-got-away setup, and a town that takes its Victorian festival far too seriously.