- 1
The highest-rated entry, and a quiet stunner. The Signed, Sealed, Delivered Postables (Eric Mabius, Kristin Booth) chase a letter written during Hurricane Katrina, trying to reunite a musician with the woman the storm scattered him from. Rated 8.0. It's the whole heart of the show in one story: love delayed by tragedy, and a team that refuses to let the gap stand. Soulful, threaded with music, and sincere to its bones. A standout whether you know these characters or you're meeting them cold.
- 2
A big one for series fans: the Postables deliver divorce papers to a couple who've since reconciled, on the very day Oliver's long-missing wife reappears from Paris. Rated 7.6, with Poppy Montgomery. So the second chances pile up, including the lead's own tangled marriage. This is the show at its most emotionally knotted, all forgiveness and the hard work of moving forward. Sincere, a touch melancholy, and a real turning point in the saga.
- 3
Bethany Joy Lenz and Tyler Hynes in a comedy of errors: Emily is sent to her ex's hometown for work, and his family wrongly assumes the two of them are still together. Rated 6.9 across more than 3,000 votes. So the exes get shoved back into proximity by a misunderstanding, with a fake-relationship wrinkle and a real second-chance pull underneath. Hynes and Lenz are a delight, and the comic energy stays high. A fun, slightly farcical holiday rom-com.
- 4
Love Strikes Twice
2021 · 84 min★ 6.9Katie Findlay's Maggie, in a fraying marriage, wishes for a do-over and wakes up fifteen years in the past, where she has to decide whether to choose her husband all over again. Rated 6.9. It's a time-travel second chance about loving the same person as a daily decision rather than a one-time event, with a historic library to save and some future legal knowledge put to mischievous use. Thoughtful and warm, a clever spin on would-you-do-it-again.
- 5
Lacey Chabert's Josie, a New York marketing exec, returns to small-town North Carolina as the sudden guardian of her niece and nephew, and reconnects with her high-school boyfriend Cooper (Tyler Hynes). Rated 6.8 across more than 1,700 votes. The second chance arrives wrapped in grief and new responsibility, an old love rediscovered while her entire life is being rebuilt around her. Chabert and Hynes are wonderful together. Tender, heartfelt, and quietly hopeful.
- 6
Small-town baker Kelly (Erin Cahill) gets called up to a Valentine's Day baking show in New York and runs straight into her ex-fiance Andrew (Brendan Penny), who's just back from Paris. Rated 6.8. The twist: they're unknowingly competing against each other in a blind format. The second chance simmers in the off-hours between rounds, two people circling the question of whether the old spark survived the years apart. Light, food-filled, and easy to root for.
- 7
Hilarie Burton plays a businesswoman trying to sell her uptight parents on her current boyfriend, only to fall back into orbit with an old high-school flame (Paul Campbell). Rated 6.7 across more than 3,000 votes. There's a fake-relationship wrinkle layered over the second chance, and Tim Conway turns up in support. It's a breezy comedy of family pressure and rediscovered feelings, with Burton and Campbell easy to watch. Light and good-natured.
- 8
Nikki DeLoach's restless newlywed gets her wish from a Christmas Angel to be single again, then realizes the life she gave up was the one she wanted. Rated 6.7 across nearly 3,000 votes, with Andrew W. Walker as the husband. It's a wish-gone-sideways second chance in the It's a Wonderful Life mold, a do-over that becomes a quest to win him back. Festive and a touch fantastical, all about appreciating what you have. A cozy holiday what-if.
- 9
A Godwink entry, so the engine is fate, not chemistry alone: Brooke D'Orsay's Margie keeps colliding with her high-school sweetheart Pat (Sam Page) through a string of so-called Godwinks after he moves home with his sons. Rated 6.7. The second chance is reignited by coincidence after coincidence, the series' whole hook. Faith-tinged and gentle, more about providence than passion. Sweet and sincere, especially for fans of the 'based on a true story' Godwink films.
- 10
Nikki DeLoach's Jessica, a single mom running a struggling diner, gets thrown back together with her high-school boyfriend Chase (Andrew W. Walker), a pro pitcher home after a career stumble. Rated 6.6 across nearly 2,500 votes. The second chance kicks off when Chase starts coaching her son, old feelings resurfacing as both decide whether to swing big again. DeLoach and Walker have easy chemistry. Warm, small-town, and quietly hopeful. A likable pick.
- 11
Two former childhood sweethearts are forced to work side-by-side on a vineyard during a legal dispute.
- 12
Lucy wakes in a wedding dress believing she is late to marry her ex, Zach, but she has no memory of the past two years. That includes the fact that she is now engaged to another man.
- 13
Years after their spontaneous marriage was annulled, Ben and Annie discover a paperwork mistake means they are still legally married. They must decide whether to give their old relationship another chance.
- 14
Twenty years after she was last in Paris, a woman returns to the City of Light, where she reconnects with her college boyfriend and first love.
- 15
Rival house flippers, Jules Briggs (Julie Gonzalo) and Lance Waddell (Tyler Hynes), renovate dual sides of a duplex and rekindle an old romance.
- 16
A corporate executive is sent to a small town to re-brand a restaurant as part of a strategic acquisition. However, the iconic diner happens to be in her hometown where she hasn't been in years, and the owner is her high school sweetheart.
- 17
With the help of his two precocious kids, a widower reconnects with his high school sweetheart, who just happens to be one of the biggest pop stars on the planet.
- 18
Two news broadcasters who previously were in love fight for a position as a morning talk show host that they both want, ultimately finding what made them like each other so much in the first place.
- 19
Audrey's long-lost love Terry returns to her life after years apart, reopening a relationship amid the strain of caring for her family. Their reunion prompts Audrey to face the pain and isolation she has carried.
- 20
Second Honeymoon
2001 · 120 min★ 5.4Career versus family prioritiesWedding Anniversary settingResort/VacationA couple on the verge of divorce take a second honeymoon after their family surprises them with an anniversary trip. The getaway asks whether their marriage can be repaired.
- 21
Erin and Mike were college sweethearts before meeting again at her daughter's flag-football practice. Coaching the team brings them together and rekindles their old connection.
- 22
A year after their separation, Lauren and Kevin focus on raising their young son Charlie together. However, Kevin harbors a desire to make them a whole family again.
- 23
A director returns to a Shakespeare festival and runs into an old flame. Their renewed sparring brings their former relationship back into the story.
About this list
23 movies · Updated 2026-09-26
A prior romantic relationship or missed romantic connection must receive a meaningful second chance. Family reunions and second chances unrelated to a couple do not qualify. The list follows saved IMDb rating.
These couples have history before the film begins. An old partner returns, a relationship breaks and resumes, or a choice opens another path for people who already loved each other. The renewed romance has to matter to the plot.
Frequently asked questions
What is second-chance romance in a Hallmark movie?
It's the trope where two people who once loved each other, or let the right person go, get another shot, usually through a hometown return, a do-over wish, or a reunion. The shared history is what makes the chemistry feel earned.