Hallmark Second-Chance Romance Movies

Ranked by IMDb average rating, drawn from the films our database flags with the second-chance romance trope.

1. 1
   

   Signed, Sealed, Delivered: Higher Ground

   2017 · 84 min★ 8.0

   The highest-rated entry, and a quiet stunner. The Signed, Sealed, Delivered Postables (Eric Mabius, Kristin Booth) chase a letter written during Hurricane Katrina, trying to reunite a musician with the woman the storm scattered him from. Rated 8.0. It's the whole heart of the show in one story: love delayed by tragedy, and a team that refuses to let the gap stand. Soulful, threaded with music, and sincere to its bones. A standout whether you know these characters or you're meeting them cold.

2. 2
   

   Signed, Sealed, Delivered: The Impossible Dream

   2015 · 84 min★ 7.8

   More Signed, Sealed, Delivered, with the team decoding a letter that might prove a soldier missing in action is still alive. Rated 7.8, with Mark Valley joining the regulars. The second-chance thread runs straight through the reunions the Postables make possible, families and loves handed another shot, alongside Rita's pageant subplot. It's patriotic and gentle, built for anyone who loves watching these four put the lost back together. Quietly stirring without straining for it.

3. 3
   

   Signed, Sealed, Delivered: From Paris with Love

   2015 · 84 min★ 7.6

   A big one for series fans: the Postables deliver divorce papers to a couple who've since reconciled, on the very day Oliver's long-missing wife reappears from Paris. Rated 7.6, with Poppy Montgomery. So the second chances pile up, including the lead's own tangled marriage. This is the show at its most emotionally knotted, all forgiveness and the hard work of moving forward. Sincere, a touch melancholy, and a real turning point in the saga.

4. 4
   

   Three Wise Men and a Baby

   2022 · 84 min★ 7.5

   Three estranged brothers (Paul Campbell, Tyler Hynes, Andrew W. Walker) reunite to mind a baby left at a fire station, and the chaos hands them a second chance at being a family. Rated 7.5 across more than 4,000 votes. The do-over here is fraternal as much as romantic, old grievances getting patched over diapers and a decorating contest. Funny, big-hearted, and a rare male-led Hallmark. A genuine crowd-pleaser that earns every bit of its warmth.

5. 5
   

   Five More Minutes

   2021 · 83 min★ 7.5

   Nikki DeLoach's Clara comes home to help run her late grandfather's Christmas shop and reconnects with her high-school sweetheart, Logan. Rated 7.5. There's a soft supernatural thread (a mysteriously helpful new employee) and a found journal that swings the past back open. A second chance at a hometown love, wrapped in grief and nostalgia and low December light. It gets you a little teary, in the good way. Lovely company for a slow holiday evening.

6. 6
   

   Time for Him to Come Home for Christmas

   2022 · 84 min★ 7.4

   Holland Roden and Tyler Hynes: a grieving journalist gets a wrong-number voicemail from a man pleading for a second chance with someone else, and sets out to deliver the message before Christmas. Rated 7.4. The case reopens her own buried loss and reconnects her with an estranged friend, so the second chances multiply. It's romance braided with a light mystery and a snow-globe clue, clever and emotionally satisfying, with two very appealing leads. A strong holiday pick.

7. 7
   

   Jesse Stone: Lost in Paradise

   2015 · 86 min★ 7.3

   A real change of pace: Tom Selleck's weary, recovering Jesse Stone takes a cold-case consulting job and circles the possibility of a second chance, personally and professionally. Rated 7.3 across more than 4,000 votes. This is the brooding, dramatic, mystery end of the catalog, not a twinkly romance, so set your expectations accordingly. Selleck is excellent, the tone is moody, the heart sits buried deep. Come for the character study. I'm giving away no solutions here.

8. 8
   

   Mystery 101: Dead Talk

   2019 · 86 min★ 7.3

   Jill Wagner's mystery professor Amy heads to a Seattle conference and runs straight into her ex, just as a tech mogul turns up dead. Rated 7.3. It's a Mystery 101 entry, so the whodunit shares the screen with a rekindling thread between Amy and Detective Travis (Kristoffer Polaha). The second chance is the slow-renewing spark between two people who already have history. Light, breezy, and built for fans of cozy mysteries with a romantic undertow. The culprit stays a secret here.

9. 9
   

   A Dickens of a Holiday!

   2021 · 84 min★ 7.2

   Brooke D'Orsay's Cassie recruits a hometown-hero action star (Kristoffer Polaha) to headline her town's A Christmas Carol production, reopening an old high-school spark. Rated 7.2. The second chance belongs to two former classmates thrown back together by a festival in crisis, with family reconciliation and a Victorian-obsessed town for backdrop. A theatrical holiday romance about going home and finding what you left behind. Sweet, charming, and very easy to love.

10. 10
    

    Take Me Back for Christmas

    2023 · 84 min★ 7.1

    Vanessa Lengies stars as Renée, who makes a Christmas wish for a different life and gets the chance to reconsider the love she already has. Rated 7.1, with Corey Sevier, who also directed. It's a second-chance story with a be-careful-what-you-wish-for twist, leaning into the warm-fantasy side of Hallmark. Cozy and a touch whimsical, all about realizing what you'd actually miss if it were gone. A gentle holiday what-if for a low-key night.

11. 11
    

    Follow the Stars Home

    2001 · 103 min★ 7.1

    An older, heavier entry. Kimberly Williams-Paisley anchors the story of a mother raising a child with special needs while two men (Campbell Scott, Eric Close) move through her life across the years. Rated 7.1. It's a sweeping family drama more than a light romance, second chances at love threaded through genuine adversity. Earnest and weighty, the kind of movie that takes its time and aims straight for the heart. A good pick when you want something with real ballast.

12. 12
    

    Next Stop, Christmas

    2021 · 84 min★ 7.0

    Lyndsy Fonseca's lonely surgeon Angie boards a commuter train that drops her back in 2011, where she can rethink the choices that changed everything, including who she loved. Rated 7.0, with Lea Thompson and Christopher Lloyd in an unmissable Back to the Future wink. It's a time-travel second chance: revisit the fork in the road, choose again. High-concept, festive, and unembarrassed about it. A blast for anyone who likes their romance with a sci-fi sparkle.

13. 13
    

    A Country Wedding

    2015 · 86 min★ 6.9

    Jesse Metcalfe plays a country star home to sell his childhood house before a high-profile wedding, where he reconnects with the best friend (Autumn Reeser) he once 'married' in a mock ceremony at thirteen. Rated 6.9 across more than 3,400 votes. The second chance is a childhood love rediscovered just as he's about to marry someone else, that old promise resurfacing at the worst possible moment. Music, hometown roots, and two appealing leads. Warm and gently dramatic.

14. 14
    

    An Unexpected Christmas

    2021 · 83 min★ 6.9

    Bethany Joy Lenz and Tyler Hynes in a comedy of errors: Emily is sent to her ex's hometown for work, and his family wrongly assumes the two of them are still together. Rated 6.9 across more than 3,000 votes. So the exes get shoved back into proximity by a misunderstanding, with a fake-relationship wrinkle and a real second-chance pull underneath. Hynes and Lenz are a delight, and the comic energy stays high. A fun, slightly farcical holiday rom-com.

15. 15
    

    Love Strikes Twice

    2021 · 84 min★ 6.9

    Katie Findlay's Maggie, in a fraying marriage, wishes for a do-over and wakes up fifteen years in the past, where she has to decide whether to choose her husband all over again. Rated 6.9. It's a time-travel second chance about loving the same person as a daily decision rather than a one-time event, with a historic library to save and some future legal knowledge put to mischievous use. Thoughtful and warm, a clever spin on would-you-do-it-again.

16. 16
    

    The Angel Tree

    2020 · 84 min★ 6.9

    Jill Wagner's writer Rebecca returns to her hometown to unmask the secret benefactor behind a wish-granting Angel Tree, and reconnects with her childhood friend Matthew (Lucas Bryant). Rated 6.9. The second chance is a friendship rekindling into something more, set against a town tradition she might have to expose for a career-making story. Cozy, faintly magical, and built on the tug between ambition and home. A warm-glow holiday watch with a real little moral knot.

17. 17
    

    A Zest for Death: A Hannah Swensen Mystery

    2023 · 84 min★ 6.9

    Alison Sweeney's baker-sleuth Hannah Swensen stumbles on a body during a house hunt and, while cracking the case, works through a rough patch with her on-again partner Mike (Cameron Mathison). Rated 6.9. It's a Hannah Swensen Mystery, so the second-chance romance simmers right alongside the investigation, two people feeling their way back to each other. Cozy, food-filled, and gently suspenseful. A treat for fans of the series, and the culprit stays under wraps here.

18. 18
    

    A December Bride

    2016 · 86 min★ 6.8

    Jessica Lowndes plays Layla, dreading her cousin's wedding to Layla's own ex-fiancé, until an acquaintance (Daniel Lissing) blurts out that he and Layla are engaged. Rated 6.8 across more than 3,700 votes. The fake engagement hands her a second chance at love in the least likely place imaginable. It's a fake-relationship and second-chance blend with a December-wedding glow, charming and a little soapy and very holiday. A fan-favorite cozy romance.

19. 19
    

    On the Twelfth Day of Christmas

    2015 · 84 min★ 6.8

    Brooke Nevin's Maggie discovers that the kind stranger who once helped her through a blizzard (Robin Dunne) has moved to town as a Christmas-hating radio DJ, and sets out to repay him by reviving his holiday spirit. Rated 6.8 across more than 2,300 votes. The second chance is a long-deferred connection finally getting its moment, delivered via anonymous Twelve-Days-of-Christmas gifts. Nostalgic and sweet, built on a lovely repay-a-kindness hook. A warm seasonal pick.

20. 20
    

    Sweet Carolina

    2021 · 84 min★ 6.8

    Lacey Chabert's Josie, a New York marketing exec, returns to small-town North Carolina as the sudden guardian of her niece and nephew, and reconnects with her high-school boyfriend Cooper (Tyler Hynes). Rated 6.8 across more than 1,700 votes. The second chance arrives wrapped in grief and new responsibility, an old love rediscovered while her entire life is being rebuilt around her. Chabert and Hynes are wonderful together. Tender, heartfelt, and quietly hopeful.

21. 21
    

    Open by Christmas

    2021 · 84 min★ 6.8

    Alison Sweeney's Nicky finds an unopened Christmas card from a high-school secret admirer, and she and her best friend Simone (Erica Durance) set out years later to track down whoever wrote it. Rated 6.8. The second chance here is sweetly literal: a kindness that went unanswered, finally getting its reply. Brennan Elliott rounds out the cast. It's a gentle holiday mystery built on the ache of a missed connection, more nostalgic than dramatic. Easy, warm company.

22. 22
    

    Roadhouse Romance

    2021 · 84 min★ 6.8

    Country singer Lauren Alaina plays Callie, an Army vet home to find her family's roadhouse struggling and her first love moved on, just as a stranded Hollywood director (Tyler Hynes) lands in town. Rated 6.8. The old flame is one thread; the bigger pull is the new spark over country music and a lost BBQ recipe. Hynes is the draw here. Warm and a little twangy, with a save-the-restaurant heart underneath. A pleasant watch for a slow afternoon.

23. 23
    

    The Secret Ingredient

    2020 · 82 min★ 6.8

    Small-town baker Kelly (Erin Cahill) gets called up to a Valentine's Day baking show in New York and runs straight into her ex-fiance Andrew (Brendan Penny), who's just back from Paris. Rated 6.8. The twist: they're unknowingly competing against each other in a blind format. The second chance simmers in the off-hours between rounds, two people circling the question of whether the old spark survived the years apart. Light, food-filled, and easy to root for.

24. 24
    

    Ships in the Night: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery

    2020 · 84 min★ 6.8

    A Martha's Vineyard Mystery, so set expectations: Jesse Metcalfe's retired Boston detective Jeff Jackson teams with local doctor and old flame Zee (Sarah Lind) to solve a gallery murder. Rated 6.8. The romance is a slow-burning subplot, not the engine, the case comes first. The second chance is the unfinished thing between Jeff and Zee, picked up across an investigation. Scenic, low-key, and built for cozy-mystery fans. The killer stays a secret here.

25. 25
    

    Ms. Christmas Comes to Town

    2023 · 84 min★ 6.8

    Erica Durance plays Gail, a beloved shopping-channel host known as 'Ms. Christmas' who, after a hard diagnosis, sets out on a farewell tour to spread holiday cheer. Rated 6.8, with Barbara Niven and Brennan Elliott. Two romances bloom on the road, including Gail reconnecting with a former fiance, so the second chance is one strand in a story really about legacy. Bittersweet and tender, heavier than the usual holiday fare. A weepier pick.

26. 26
    

    Family History Mysteries: Buried Past

    2023 · 84 min★ 6.8

    A Family History Mysteries entry, so the sleuthing leads: Janel Parrish's forensic genealogist Sophie searches for a long-lost man whose son urgently needs a bone-marrow donor, and the hunt brings the donor's twin Jackson (Niall Matter) back into her orbit. Rated 6.8. The rekindled romance rides alongside the case rather than driving it. Twisty, earnest, and a little heavier than a standard Hallmark, with real stakes. Good for fans who like a mystery with their reunion.

27. 27
    

    Rise and Shine, Benedict Stone

    2021 · 84 min★ 6.8

    Tom Everett Scott plays Benedict Stone, a jeweler whose ten-year marriage to Emilia has hit a breaking point, until a teenage niece arrives and launches a campaign to win her back. Rated 6.8. This is a second chance at a marriage rather than a lost youthful love, which gives it more weight than most. There's a buried family secret and a brother estrangement folded in. Quieter and more grown-up than the holiday crowd. A thoughtful pick.

28. 28
    

    Surprised by Love

    2015 · 84 min★ 6.7

    Hilarie Burton plays a businesswoman trying to sell her uptight parents on her current boyfriend, only to fall back into orbit with an old high-school flame (Paul Campbell). Rated 6.7 across more than 3,000 votes. There's a fake-relationship wrinkle layered over the second chance, and Tim Conway turns up in support. It's a breezy comedy of family pressure and rediscovered feelings, with Burton and Campbell easy to watch. Light and good-natured.

29. 29
    

    A Dream of Christmas

    2016 · 84 min★ 6.7

    Nikki DeLoach's restless newlywed gets her wish from a Christmas Angel to be single again, then realizes the life she gave up was the one she wanted. Rated 6.7 across nearly 3,000 votes, with Andrew W. Walker as the husband. It's a wish-gone-sideways second chance in the It's a Wonderful Life mold, a do-over that becomes a quest to win him back. Festive and a touch fantastical, all about appreciating what you have. A cozy holiday what-if.

30. 30
    

    Small Town Christmas

    2018 · 85 min★ 6.7

    Ashley Newbrough's novelist Nell visits the small town that inspired her book and comes face to face with Emmett (Kristoffer Polaha), the man who stood her up six years earlier and vanished. Rated 6.7 across more than 2,000 votes. The second chance is loaded with old resentment, since he's now raising an orphaned niece and she's wrestling with unfinished feelings. There's a save-the-town subplot too. Charming, with real friction under the snow. A solid pick.

31. 31
    

    Her Pen Pal

    2021 · 86 min★ 6.7

    Wedding planner Victoria (Mallory Jansen) heads to Paris for her best friend's wedding, finds her ex has brought a date, and reconnects with Jacques, her French childhood pen pal (Joshua Sasse). Rated 6.7. The second chance is a long-distance friendship from decades back finally meeting in person, set against chateaus and Parisian streets. It's a love-triangle holiday-free romance with a travel-glossy backdrop and genuine charm. A nice change of scenery from the usual snowy small town.

32. 32
    

    A Godwink Christmas: Second Chance, First Love

    2020 · 87 min★ 6.7

    A Godwink entry, so the engine is fate, not chemistry alone: Brooke D'Orsay's Margie keeps colliding with her high-school sweetheart Pat (Sam Page) through a string of so-called Godwinks after he moves home with his sons. Rated 6.7. The second chance is reignited by coincidence after coincidence, the series' whole hook. Faith-tinged and gentle, more about providence than passion. Sweet and sincere, especially for fans of the 'based on a true story' Godwink films.

33. 33
    

    The Christmas Bow

    2020 · 83 min★ 6.7

    Lucia Micarelli plays Kate, a violinist whose hand injury derails her career just as she lands a philharmonic seat, sending her home to recover with childhood friend and physical therapist Patrick (Michael Rady). Rated 6.7. The second chance is an old bond rekindled through her rehab, music threaded all the way through. Micarelli is a real violinist, which gives the playing scenes a lovely authenticity. Gentle, heartfelt, and a little melancholy. A warm holiday watch.

34. 34
    

    Twas the Night Before Christmas

    2022 · 84 min★ 6.7

    Torrey DeVitto's former child star Madison tries to reinvent herself by directing a courtroom play about who really wrote 'Twas the Night Before Christmas, reuniting her with former co-star Connor (Zane Holtz). Rated 6.7. The second chance is two old screen partners finding their way back, with a genuinely odd twist: actors who may be the actual ghosts of the historical figures. Quirky, theatrical, and more unusual than most. Worth it for the strange premise alone.

35. 35
    

    Poisoned in Paradise: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery

    2021 · 84 min★ 6.7

    Another Martha's Vineyard Mystery, so the case leads and the romance follows: Jesse Metcalfe's Jeff Jackson and medical examiner Zee (Sarah Lind) investigate a waitress's poisoning while a strange deposit lands in Zee's account. Rated 6.7. The second-chance thread between them deepens across the investigation rather than carrying it. Scenic, moody, and steadier than sparkly. Built for fans of the cozy-detective format. No solutions given away here.

36. 36
    

    Switched for Christmas

    2017 · 83 min★ 6.6

    Candace Cameron Bure plays identical twins who swap lives for the holidays, each convinced the other's grass is greener. Rated 6.6 across more than 3,600 votes, with Bure's real daughter Natasha in the cast. The second-chance romance is one of two that bloom once the sisters step into each other's worlds. It's a body-swap comedy of errors with a double helping of holiday charm. Silly in the best way, and a fan favorite.

37. 37
    

    Matchmaker Santa

    2012 · 75 min★ 6.6

    Lacey Chabert's baker Melanie gets stranded in a charming town on the way to meet her boyfriend's family, thrown together with his best friend Dean while a hitchhiking Santa nudges fate along. Rated 6.6 across nearly 2,700 votes, with Florence Henderson and John Ratzenberger. The second chance is twofold, including the boyfriend rekindling things with his own old flame. Magical, a touch screwball, and unabashedly Christmassy. A warm early-era Chabert charmer.

38. 38
    

    The Perfect Catch

    2017 · 83 min★ 6.6

    Nikki DeLoach's Jessica, a single mom running a struggling diner, gets thrown back together with her high-school boyfriend Chase (Andrew W. Walker), a pro pitcher home after a career stumble. Rated 6.6 across nearly 2,500 votes. The second chance kicks off when Chase starts coaching her son, old feelings resurfacing as both decide whether to swing big again. DeLoach and Walker have easy chemistry. Warm, small-town, and quietly hopeful. A likable pick.

39. 39
    

    The Nine Kittens of Christmas

    2021 · 84 min★ 6.6

    Brandon Routh and Kimberley Sustad reunite as exes Zachary and Marilee, thrown back together at Christmas when a litter of nine kittens needs homes. Rated 6.6 across more than 2,200 votes. The second chance plays out over kitten adoptions and a choice between her ambitious life in Miami and the hometown she left. It's the sequel to the Nine Lives of Christmas films, cozy and low-stakes by design. Catnip for animal lovers, and genuinely sweet.

40. 40
    

    The Russell Girl

    2008 · 120 min★ 6.6

    The heaviest entry by far. Amber Tamblyn's Sarah comes home carrying a leukemia diagnosis she won't share, and is forced to confront a childhood tragedy and the neighbor it estranged her from. Rated 6.6, with Jennifer Ehle and a young Paul Wesley. This is a serious family drama, not a light romance; the second chance is as much about self-forgiveness as love. Slow, weighty, and genuinely moving. Watch it when you want real emotional ballast.