Hallmark Romantic Comedy Movies

Ranked by IMDb average rating, highest first. Includes films Hallmark tags as comedic, from screwball farces to romances with a strong comic streak. Recent unrated 2024 titles are placed last.

1. 1
   

   Jingle & Bell's Christmas Star

   2012 · 30 min★ 7.2

   Rated 7.2, and the asterisk at the top of this list. It is a 30-minute animated short, not a feature rom-com, so go in knowing that. Sofia moves from sunny Palm City to snowy Pineville right before Christmas and hates everything about it, until her husky pup Bell and a neighbor kid named Andrew pull her into the town's tree-star contest. Gentle, kid-friendly, and very short. Charming for little ones, but not the fast-talking adult comedy the rest of this list delivers.

2. 2
   

   Round and Round

   2023 · 90 min★ 7.1

   Rated 7.1 with over 1,500 votes, and one of the genuinely funniest things Hallmark has made. Rachel (Vic Michaelis) is stuck reliving the seventh night of Hanukkah at her parents' party, and the only person who might help her break the loop is Zach (Bryan Greenberg), the sweet nerd her grandma keeps trying to set her up with. The premise leans on a magic family dreidel and a "nerd squad" that solves time loops with comic-book logic. Quick, warm, and self-aware. If you want banter over schmaltz, start here.

3. 3
   

   Roughing It

   2002 · 185 min★ 7.0

   Rated 7, and an outlier worth flagging up front: this is a 185-minute period adventure about a young Mark Twain chasing silver out West, not a romance at all. James Garner and Ned Beatty co-star. The comedy is in the tall-tale misadventures, a cow shot with an Allen pistol, a tarantula panic in a bunkhouse, deathbed confessions retracted the moment an inn turns up fifteen yards away. A long, shaggy, episodic watch. Pick it for the frontier yarns, not for a meet-cute.

4. 4
   

   An Unexpected Christmas

   2021 · 83 min★ 6.9

   Rated 6.9 with over 3,100 votes, and a fan-favorite for a reason. Emily (Bethany Joy Lenz) gets sent to her ex's hometown for work and arrives at the train station just as his family scoops him up, all of them assuming she and Jamie (Tyler Hynes) are still together. Cue a fake-relationship Christmas built on a misunderstanding nobody wants to correct. Hynes and Lenz have real comic timing, and the whole thing is breezy and quick. One of the better second-chance comedies here.

5. 5
   

   Love on the Air

   2015 · 84 min★ 6.9

   Rated 6.9 with over 1,800 votes. Sonia (Alison Sweeney) is a radio host preaching female independence who gets publicly dumped on air by her fiance, who borrows the catchphrase of cynical shock jock Nick (Jonathan Scarfe). Their station manager smells ratings and forces the two rivals to co-host a morning show together. The on-air sparring and the endlessly repeated breakup line make it. A solid enemies-to-lovers comedy, with Nick's dog Clooney softening him up on schedule.

6. 6
   

   Naughty or Nice

   2011 · 83 min★ 6.5

   Rated 6.5 with over 3,100 votes, and gleefully odd. Krissy Kringle, an ad exec who lives on Candy Cane Lane and is saddled with that name, gets fired before Christmas and then receives Santa's actual Naughty or Nice list, which reveals everyone's private secrets. Hilarie Burton Morgan leads. The book "tinkles" when it exposes a sin, the secrets get wonderfully petty, and there is a mall elf faking an Australian accent from watching Crocodile Dundee. A comedy about light blackmail, basically. I love it.

7. 7
   

   The Christmas House 2: Deck Those Halls

   2021 · 84 min★ 6.4

   Rated 6.4 with over 1,300 votes. The Mitchell brothers (Robert Buckley, Jonathan Bennett) go head to head to build the better Christmas House, an over-the-top home decorating face-off with the family caught in the middle. The competitive-sibling angle gives it more comic energy than the average decorating movie, and the cast clearly has fun. A warm, busy holiday sequel. Lighter on the romance than the title suggests, but the brotherly rivalry carries the jokes.

8. 8
   

   Rescuing Christmas

   2023 · 98 min★ 6.4

   Rated 6.4 with over 900 votes, and a fun high-concept swing. Erin (Rachael Leigh Cook), an anti-Christmas photographer, is granted three wishes by Santa's elves and accidentally wishes the whole holiday out of existence, then has to put it back. Think the movie Yesterday, but for Christmas. The elves discuss legal provisos and HR workshops, Santa vacations in Duluth, and someone wishes for mac-and-cheese ice cream. The execution is uneven, but the premise is a hoot. Sam Page co-stars.

9. 9
   

   A Christmas Detour

   2015 · 85 min★ 6.2

   Rated 6.2 with over 3,600 votes. An anxious bride-to-be, Paige (Candace Cameron Bure), gets her flight diverted by a snowstorm and ends up crammed into a rental car with a cynical stranger (Paul Greene) and a bickering married couple, all racing to NYC for Christmas. The carry-on vision board and the running debate over whether her laugh has an endearing snort are the comic highlights. A road-trip comedy with a likable ensemble. Easy, warm, and quick.

10. 10
    

    Haul Out the Holly

    2022 · 84 min★ 6.0

    Rated 6 with over 3,800 votes, the first Haul Out the Holly. Emily (Lacey Chabert) comes home for the holidays only to find her parents leaving on a trip and a relentless HOA, led by Stephen Tobolowsky and Melissa Peterman, determined to draft her into the neighborhood Christmas festivities. The aggressive holiday-bylaw comedy and the deadpan supporting cast are the draw. A light enemies-to-neighbors romance with Wes Brown. More charming than laugh-out-loud, but the HOA bits land.

11. 11
    

    I'm Not Ready for Christmas

    2015 · 84 min★ 6.0

    Rated 6 with over 2,200 votes, and one of the strongest pure-comedy premises here. Holly (Alicia Witt), an ad exec who lies to manage her whole life, gets hit with a Christmas curse after breaking a promise to her niece: she physically cannot tell a lie. The professional chaos that follows is the joke, including a confession that her rental skates smell like her grandmother's corned beef and cabbage. Witt commits fully. A genuinely funny forced-honesty comedy.

12. 12
    

    Pete's Christmas

    2013 · 86 min★ 6.0

    Rated 6 with over 2,100 votes. Pete (Zachary Gordon), an overlooked middle kid, is doomed to relive the worst Christmas of his life over and over, then slowly figures out how to use the loop to fix his family. Bailee Madison and Bruce Dern co-star. The comedy is broad and a little gross, a bed-wetting brother who blames Pete, a grandpa-grandson mooning of the neighborhood bullies, an attempt to invent pork wings. A scrappy teen Groundhog Day. Sillier than romantic, but fun.

13. 13
    

    I Married Who?

    2012 · 86 min★ 6.0

    Rated 6 with over 1,500 votes. Straight-laced Jordan (Kellie Martin) wakes up after a Vegas bachelorette party married to a movie star (Ethan Erickson) she does not remember marrying, with her real wedding to a controlling lawyer days away. The accidental marriage gets hijacked into a publicity stunt, and the movie-within-a-movie about a cop who monologues on truth, justice, and pastrami is a delight. A classic Vegas mix-up comedy. Breezy and a little bonkers.

14. 14
    

    Accidentally in Love

    2011 · 88 min★ 6.0

    Rated 6 with over 1,000 votes. Eddie (Ethan Erickson) plays Mulligan the Rabbit on a kids' show and resents every sweaty minute of it, until a fender-bender with single mom Annie (Jennie Garth) and her Mulligan-obsessed daughter rearranges his priorities. Fred Willard adds comic ballast. The rabbit-suit indignities, including a birthday-party brawl between a man in a bunny costume and a clown, supply the laughs. The story turns surprisingly tender. An odd, sweet little comedy.

15. 15
    

    Made for Each Other

    2023 · 84 min★ 5.9

    Rated 5.9 with over 800 votes, and a wild premise played straight. Rachel (Alexandra Turshen), a perfectionist sculptor sick of her mother's matchmaking, sculpts her ideal man out of clay, and a friend uses an ancient amulet to bring "Clay" to life. Then she starts actually liking a flawed, honest comedian (Matt Cohen). It is basically the Golem legend as a rom-com, complete with a magic man who wants to attend culinary school. Goofy and charming if you buy in. Manage expectations on polish.

16. 16
    

    Bad Date Chronicles

    2017 · 84 min★ 5.8

    Rated 5.8 with over 1,000 votes. Leigh (Merritt Patterson) runs a website where people post their worst dates anonymously, and when rival blogger Conner (Justin Kelly) ends up featured, the two agree to date each other to settle who is actually the bad dater. The dueling-bloggers setup gives it a built-in comic engine, and the public-embarrassment beats are the fun. A lightweight enemies-to-lovers comedy. Not top-tier, but the premise earns a few real laughs.

17. 17
    

    Smooch

    2011 · 102 min★ 5.8

    Rated 5.8 with nearly 1,000 votes, and one of the strangest setups on the list. It is a modern Frog Prince riff: an amnesiac British royal (Simon Kassianides) is mugged in San Francisco, and an 11-year-old girl who could not bring herself to dissect a frog believes her kiss turned a frog into a man. Kellie Martin plays the widowed mom who hires him as a nanny. A storybook framing device and a lot of audacity. Uneven, but you will not see another quite like it.

18. 18
    

    Perfectly Prudence

    2011 · 85 min★ 5.8

    Rated 5.8 with over 350 votes. Jane Seymour plays Prudence, the genteel host of a household-tips show, fighting a corporate takeover that wants to "sex up" the program with product placement and a bikini-weather-girl co-host. The comedy is broad and physical, hot coffee in the lap, a catnip Maginot Line built to contain experimental cockroaches, perfume sprayed on hot bulbs until they pop. A creaky but cheerfully chaotic showbiz farce. Best for viewers who enjoy a messy comic ensemble.

19. 19
    

    Nearlyweds

    2013 · 90 min★ 5.7

    Rated 5.7 with over 1,600 votes. Three best friends learn their weddings were never legal because the minister died before signing the licenses, sending all three back to reassess the men they married. Danielle Panabaker leads. The comedy is sharp at the edges, a mother-in-law in full Sicilian-widow black, a spying scene that ends with a fall out of a tree. Notably, one couple actually stays apart, which is rare for the genre. A smarter-than-expected ensemble comedy.

20. 20
    

    Battle of the Bulbs

    2010 · 89 min★ 5.4

    Rated 5.4 with over 800 votes. Daniel Stern and Matt Frewer play feuding neighbors who escalate a Christmas-lights arms race into all-out suburban war for the brightest house on the block. The over-decorating one-upmanship is the whole joke, and both leads lean into the slapstick. A broad, cheerful holiday comedy that knows exactly what it is. Light on romance, heavy on lawn ornaments. Fun if you are in the mood for cartoonish neighbor warfare.

21. 21
    

    Family Plan

    2005 · 85 min★ 5.4

    Rated 5.4 with over 800 votes. Charlie (Tori Spelling), a career-driven exec, lies about having a husband and kid to impress her family-values-obsessed boss, then hires an out-of-work actor (Jordan Bridges) and borrows her friend's daughter to sell the lie. The boss promptly moves in next door, forcing a 24/7 charade. A young Chloe Grace Moretz plays the kid who blackmails Charlie for $100 and lip gloss. A scrappy fake-family farce, complete with a hired bug wrangler. Daffy fun.

22. 22
    

    Second Honeymoon

    2001 · 120 min★ 5.4

    Rated 5.4 with over 370 votes. Roma Downey and Tim Matheson play a couple quietly planning to split after twenty years, until a nonrefundable second-honeymoon trip to a tropical island traps them together. The forced-proximity rekindling is the engine, and the resort setting keeps it light. A gentle, old-fashioned reconciliation comedy at a full two hours. More warm than wacky. Best for viewers who like a slow, sunny do-over romance.

23. 23
    

    Dear Dumb Diary

    2013 · 84 min★ 5.3

    Rated 5.3 with over 900 votes, and a clear outlier: this is a kids' musical comedy, not an adult romance. Based on Jim Benton's books, it follows middle-schooler Jamie Kelly (Emily Alyn Lind) as she narrates her life, feuds with a too-perfect rival, and tries to save the school art program. There are stylized musical numbers about meatloaf and a dog whose defining trait is flatulence. Bright, silly, and aimed at tweens. Charming for that crowd, but not date-night material.

24. 24
    

    Santa Switch

    2013 · 90 min★ 5.3

    Rated 5.3 with over 500 votes. Dan (Ethan Erickson), a divorcing, unemployed travel agent, gets recruited to fill in for Santa while the real one vacations in Bimini, then misuses his magic to buy his family's love and undercut his wife's new suitor. Sean Astin plays an elf. The North Pole runs on a sugar economy, there is a "Santa Card" credit card, and misused magic turns food into fruitcake. A goofy body-of-work-meets-holiday comedy. Broad, but the world-building gags amuse.

25. 25
    

    The Gambler, the Girl and the Gunslinger

    2009 · 95 min★ 4.6

    Rated 4.6 with over 270 votes, the lowest-rated title here and a true bad-movie-night pick. Dean Cain and James Tupper play a con-man gambler and a rancher who lose half a ranch, become bitter rivals, then have to team up when bandits threaten everything. It is a Western played for light comedy, and the rough edges are part of the fun. Watch it with friends and low expectations. A lovable misfire rather than a polished comedy.

26. 26
    

    Paging Mr. Darcy

    2024 · 84 min

    No settled IMDb rating yet, so it sits down here. A Jane Austen-themed comedy: Eloise (Mallory Jansen) and Sam (Will Kemp) overcome their pride and prejudice at a costumed Austen fan conference, complete with a Mr. Darcy impersonator and a ballroom. Benjamin Ayres co-stars. The book-nerd setting and the costume-ball antics promise the gentle comic friction the genre does well. One to try if you like your rom-coms with a literary wink. Check its page for a current score.

27. 27
    

    Confessions of a Christmas Letter

    2024 · 84 min

    No settled IMDb rating yet. Settie Rose (Angela Kinsey) hires struggling novelist Juan to ghostwrite her family's Christmas letter so she can finally make the neighborhood Wall of Fame, and a mix-up sparks gossip that he is engaged to her daughter Lily. The competitive-holiday-letter premise is a sharp comic hook, and Kinsey is built for this kind of farce. Silent disco parties and a mistaken-mafia theory round it out. A promising new comedy. Check its page for the latest rating.

28. 28
    

    Three Wiser Men and a Boy

    2024 · 84 min

    No settled IMDb rating yet. Three brothers (Paul Campbell, Tyler Hynes, Andrew W. Walker) come home for Christmas and scramble to save a nephew's school pageant after the director quits, while their mother debuts a new boyfriend. This trio has terrific comic chemistry, and the pageant here goes maximalist, laser tag, giant props, a robot, blow torches, a flying rig. A loud, very funny family comedy. If you liked these three together before, this is more of that.

29. 29
    

    The Groomsmen: First Look

    2024 · 82 min

    No settled IMDb rating yet. A Philadelphia pediatrician (B.J. Britt) falls for a doctor working in Bulgaria after meeting at a wedding, then navigates a long-distance romance with his two meddling best friends in tow. The running "Shake Your Groove Thing" dance the three men perform at every wedding, an 88-minute texting rule, and a proposal that ends in a run-in with Bulgarian police supply the comedy. A friendship-forward romance. Check its page for a current score.

30. 30
    

    'Twas the Date Before Christmas

    2024 · 84 min

    No settled IMDb rating yet. To stop her family from canceling the Chamberlain Family Christmas Olympics, Jessie (Amy Groening) lies that she is bringing a date, then recruits Bryan (Robert Buckley) to play the part. The full-day Olympics, a hidden-star hunt, a wrap battle, snowball dodgeball, carol-oke, are the comic centerpiece, and the family takes them very seriously. A fake-date holiday comedy with a genuine community-stakes subplot. Check its page for the latest rating.