John Christian Plummer
Writing Hallmark films since 2019. Wrote films in Mystery 101 and Mystery Island. 7 films with Jill Wagner.
- Hallmark films
- 15
- average rating of 15 rated films
- 6.8
- average weirdness, Hallmark median 4
- 3.8
Start hereThree ways into John's films
Every Hallmark film
2020s 11 films
Mystery Island: House Rules2025 Rated 6.6Weirdness 7
Mystery Island: Play for Keeps2025 Rated 6.5Weirdness 5
Mystery Island: Winner Takes All2025 Rated 6.1Weirdness 7
Curious Caterer: Grilling Season2023 Rated 6.8Weirdness 3
Mystery Island2023 Rated 5.7Weirdness 4
Curious Caterer: Dying for Chocolate2022 Rated 6.6Weirdness 2
Francesca Quinn, PI2022 Rated 6.2Weirdness 3
Mystery 101: Deadly History2021 Rated 7.4Weirdness 3
Mystery 101: Killer Timing2021 Rated 7.3Weirdness 3
Mystery 101: An Education in Murder2020 Rated 7.1Weirdness 4
Riddled with Deceit: A Martha's Vineyard Mystery2020 Rated 6.9Weirdness 3
Who John works with
Actors in their films most often
Writers most often on the same film
What turns up in John's films
Traits that show up in John's films more often than in Hallmark films overall, rarest first.
- Resort or holiday tripRare on Hallmark
3 of John's 15 films (20%). 4% of all Hallmark films.
- Lead is a teacher or professorUncommon on Hallmark
6 of John's 15 films (40%). 6% of all Hallmark films.
- A secretClassic Hallmark
11 of John's 15 films (73%). 43% of all Hallmark films.
Ratings and weirdness
Each coloured dot is one of John's films. The grey dots are every other rated Hallmark film.
Films per year
Series and guides
Featured in our guides: Small-town movies, Baking and cooking movies, Summer movies, Enemies to lovers, Second-chance romance
Questions people ask
How many Hallmark movies has John Christian Plummer been in?
We have 15 Hallmark movies on file for John Christian Plummer, from 2019 to 2025.
What kind of Hallmark movies is John Christian Plummer known for?
John is best known for romances set in small towns, often with a hidden secret.
What is John Christian Plummer's highest-rated Hallmark movie?
Mystery 101: Deadly History (2021) is John's best-reviewed Hallmark film, with a 7.4/10 audience rating.
What is John Christian Plummer's most popular Hallmark movie?
Mystery 101 (2019) has more audience votes than any other John Christian Plummer Hallmark film, so it's the one most people have seen.
What is John Christian Plummer's weirdest Hallmark movie?
Mystery Island: Winner Takes All (2025) scores 7 out of 10 on our weirdness scale.
Is John Christian Plummer still making Hallmark movies?
Yes. The most recent John Hallmark film we have is from 2025.
What was John Christian Plummer's first Hallmark movie?
Our earliest credits for John Christian Plummer are from 2019: Mystery 101, Mystery 101: Dead Talk, Mystery 101: Playing Dead, Mystery 101: Words Can Kill. Year-only dates do not establish which premiered first.
What does John Christian Plummer do in Hallmark movies?
John Christian Plummer works on Hallmark films as director and writer.
Credits come from IMDb, posters and other credits from TMDB, and ratings combine IMDb and TMDB audience scores. Weirdness and traits are HallmarkDB’s own, read from each film’s subtitles. John Christian Plummer on IMDb








