Hallmark Fall Movies

Ranked by IMDb average rating, highest first. Includes films Hallmark tags as set in fall, which overlaps with Halloween and Thanksgiving titles and several autumn-set cozy mysteries.

1. 1
   

   Good Witch: Secrets of Grey House

   2016 · 84 min★ 7.8

   Rated 7.8 with over 400 votes, the top score here. A Good Witch movie set around a Halloween book launch: Cassie (Catherine Bell) helps a famous author realize her fictional town is based on the real history of Grey House, while Mayor Martha tries to remake Middleton to impress a rival. Be clear-eyed, this is a gentle-magic Halloween special, not a fall romance. But the autumn book-festival setting is cozy, and the cast is the comfortable Good Witch ensemble. Warm and low-stakes.

2. 2
   

   Good Witch Halloween

   2015 · 82 min★ 7.6

   Rated 7.6 with over 400 votes. Middleton gears up for its Harvest Festival as a stranger arrives at Grey House hunting a hidden family fortune, and Cassie's daughter Grace wrestles with her own magical heritage. The harvest-fair backdrop, hay maze, costume pageant, autumn decorations, makes this one of the more genuinely fall-flavored Good Witch entries. It is still a supernatural cozy rather than a romance, so set expectations there. A pleasant seasonal watch for fans of Middleton.

3. 3
   

   Good Witch Spellbound

   2017 · 94 min★ 7.4

   Rated 7.4 with over 380 votes. The Middleton shops compete for best Halloween decoration while a 150-year-old prophecy turns up in the City Hall basement and starts to look like a curse. The shop-decorating contest and the autumn-town panic give it real seasonal texture. Catherine Bell and James Denton anchor the regular cast. A spooky-cozy Good Witch special, more atmosphere than romance. Comfortable and easy if you already love the franchise.

4. 4
   

   Good Witch: Tale of Two Hearts

   2018 · 120 min★ 7.4

   Rated 7.4 with over 300 votes, and the longest Good Witch entry at two hours. As Cassie and Sam plan a Halloween wedding, their venue floods and the town's lucky ruby goes missing from the museum, just in time for the anniversary festival and masquerade gala. The masquerade and harvest-competition-against-a-rival-town give it strong autumn-event energy. A gentle-magic Halloween special rather than a straight romance. Long but warm, and the gala dressing is a treat.

5. 5
   

   Curse from a Rose

   2019★ 7.4

   Rated 7.4 with over 250 votes. Cassie's old college roommate Autumn (Lolita Davidovich) arrives in Middleton nursing a 25-year grudge, just as the town throws a competitive Halloween triathlon and a giant pumpkin contest against rival Blairsville. The seasonal swing is the whole point: a town trying to carve over 6,000 pumpkins for a state record, a surgeon racing a hollowed-out gourd in a pumpkin regatta. A festival-forward Good Witch outing. The forgiveness arc is slight, but the autumn antics deliver.

6. 6
   

   Mystery 101: An Education in Murder

   2020 · 84 min★ 7.3

   Rated 7.3 with over 1,200 votes, and one of the better cozy mysteries here. Professor Amy (Jill Wagner) and Detective Travis (Kristoffer Polaha) reopen a closed murder case after a true-crime writer arrives at their college town claiming a colleague was wrongly convicted. The autumn college-town setting is lovely, and the Wagner-Polaha rapport is a real draw. Worth flagging this is a whodunit, not a fall romance, so come for the case. A smart, brisk Mystery 101 entry, spoiler-free here by design.

7. 7
   

   The Wedding Veil Unveiled

   2022 · 84 min★ 7.2

   Rated 7.2 with over 1,700 votes. Emma (Autumn Reeser) spends a semester in Italy researching a wedding veil said to bring love, and meets Paolo (Paolo Bernardini), heir to the lace-making family that actually created it. Lacey Chabert and Alison Sweeney appear. The Burano lace-shop setting is gorgeous, and the historical-mystery thread gives it more pull than the usual travel romance. A warm, pretty Wedding Veil entry. More golden-light getaway than crisp-leaf fall, but lovely all the same.

8. 8
   

   Jingle & Bell's Christmas Star

   2012 · 30 min★ 7.2

   Rated 7.2 with under 100 votes, and plainly mistagged for this list. It is a 30-minute animated Christmas short, not a fall feature: Sofia moves to snowy Pineville before Christmas and bonds with a neighbor over the town's tree-star contest, with two husky pups along for it. Sweet and very short, aimed at small kids. Included because the data files it under fall, but do not expect autumn or a romance. A gentle holiday cartoon, full stop.

9. 9
   

   The Good Witch

   2008 · 89 min★ 7.1

   Rated 7.1 with over 5,100 votes, the most-rated film here and the original Good Witch movie. A mysterious woman, Cassie (Catherine Bell), moves into a supposedly haunted house in Middleton and slowly wins over a wary town and the local police chief (Chris Potter). This is the front door to the whole franchise, with a faintly spooky autumn atmosphere. More gentle-magic drama than romance or seasonal showcase. Start here if you have never met Middleton; it sets up everything that follows.

10. 10
    

    The Good Witch's Garden

    2009 · 86 min★ 7.1

    Rated 7.1 with over 2,600 votes, the second Good Witch movie. As Middleton preps its bicentennial, a stranger turns up claiming to be the rightful heir to Grey House, and Cassie must expose the fraud to keep her home. A truth-telling plant and a vine that hugs people's ankles supply the gentle weirdness. A cozy, low-stakes sequel set in autumn rather than built around it. Comfortable franchise comfort food, best for viewers already fond of the town.

11. 11
    

    All of My Heart: The Wedding

    2018 · 85 min★ 7.1

    Rated 7.1 with over 1,500 votes, the All of My Heart wedding entry. Jenny and Brian (Lacey Chabert, Brennan Elliott) plan a fall wedding at their country inn just as a long-lost relative demands a six-figure buyout of the estate. Four goats are treated as major characters, and a "singing sink" counts as a selling point. The autumn-inn setting and the save-the-home stakes are warm. Edward Asner appears. A sweet, community-rallies romance. Genuinely fall-flavored, and an easy watch.

12. 12
    

    The Wedding Cottage

    2023 · 84 min★ 7.1

    Rated 7.1 with over 1,400 votes. Vanessa (Erin Krakow), a wedding-guide author, promises a contest-winning military couple a dream wedding at a Vermont cottage, then discovers the venue is closed and falling apart, and its owner (Brendan Penny) is a creatively blocked sculptor. A family of raccoons effectively holds the contest hostage. The renovation-against-the-clock setup and the Vermont setting suit the season. A warm fixer-upper romance, with Krakow and Penny easy together.

13. 13
    

    Mystery 101: Words Can Kill

    2019 · 84 min★ 7.1

    Rated 7.1 with over 1,200 votes, an earlier Mystery 101. When a guest at the college book festival is killed, professor Amy (Jill Wagner) clashes with Detective Travis (Kristoffer Polaha) after he arrests the wrong person, and she sets out to prove it. The autumn book-festival setting is a nice seasonal touch. Flagging clearly that this is a cozy whodunit, not a fall romance. Tightly plotted and spoiler-free here. A solid pick if you want a case rather than a meet-cute.

14. 14
    

    Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: A Very Foul Play

    2019 · 85 min★ 7.0

    Rated 7 with over 1,300 votes, an Aurora Teagarden mystery. Aurora (Candace Cameron Bure) and friends head to a resort for a true-crime convention and a mystery-dinner-theater night, until a real murder happens on stage and her cousin is found holding the weapon. Marilu Henner co-stars. The murder-during-a-murder-mystery hook is fun. This is a cozy whodunit, not a fall romance, and I will leave the culprit well alone. A breezy, comfortable entry for cozy-crime fans.

15. 15
    

    Falling for Vermont

    2017 · 84 min★ 6.9

    Rated 6.9 with over 2,300 votes, and one of the most genuinely autumnal romances here. Best-selling author Angela (Julie Gonzalo) crashes her car in Vermont, loses her memory, and is taken in by a kind local doctor (Benjamin Ayres) and his kids as the town preps its Fall Fest. The amnesia is restored, oddly, by an allergic reaction to pecan brownies. The fall-foliage setting and the slow rebuild of her real self make it cozy and warm. A lovely crisp-weather watch.

16. 16
    

    The Good Witch's Family

    2011 · 83 min★ 6.9

    Rated 6.9 with over 2,100 votes, the Good Witch's Family. Cassie's manipulative cousin Abigail turns up to sow discord just as Cassie (Catherine Bell) runs for mayor to stop a bridge project threatening Middleton. A perfume called "chemistry in a bottle" and a compass that points the wrong way to find your destiny keep it odd. A gentle-magic franchise entry set in fall rather than steeped in it. Cozy and familiar, best for viewers who already live in Middleton.

17. 17
    

    The Good Witch's Destiny

    2013 · 82 min★ 6.9

    Rated 6.9 with over 1,700 votes, the Good Witch's Destiny. As Cassie (Catherine Bell) plans a birthday party, a record October heatwave and a string of misfortunes revive the legend of the "Grey Lady" who vanished on her own birthday, and stepdaughter Lori digs into the history. A magical satchel with a secret pocket and skunk-smelling incense add the franchise's usual gentle weirdness. More family drama than romance, set loosely in autumn. Comfortable Middleton comfort food.

18. 18
    

    The Good Witch's Wonder

    2014 · 84 min★ 6.9

    Rated 6.9 with over 1,700 votes, the Good Witch's Wonder. Cassie (Catherine Bell) hunts for a stolen family memento and shelters a mysterious newcomer fleeing a dark past, while her stepson rushes his wedding into a single week. A magical camera obscura that helps people find focus and love is the standout oddity. A gentle-magic franchise entry, autumn-set rather than fall-themed. Warm and low-stakes, and best enjoyed as part of the wider Middleton run.

19. 19
    

    Crossword Mysteries: Proposing Murder

    2019 · 83 min★ 6.9

    Rated 6.9 with over 1,300 votes, a Crossword mysteries entry. Crossword editor Tess (Lacey Chabert) dives into a murder investigation alongside detective Logan (Brennan Elliott) in a brisk New York-set whodunit. The puzzle-solving hook gives the cases a likable hook, and the Chabert-Elliott chemistry carries the series. This is a cozy mystery rather than a fall romance, so come for the crime. Spoiler-free here. A pleasant pick for crossword and cozy-crime fans alike.

20. 20
    

    Crossword Mysteries: Abracadaver

    2019 · 85 min★ 6.9

    Rated 6.9 with over 1,300 votes, a Crossword mysteries outing. When a magician dies during a "bullet catch" trick at the Magic Manor, Tess (Lacey Chabert) and Logan (Brennan Elliott) uncover a world of illusions, society thefts, and a killer who seems to vanish. The magic-act setting is a fun change of scenery. A cozy whodunit, not a fall romance, and I will not touch the solution. The puzzle-meets-stage-magic angle makes it one of the more inventive entries here.

21. 21
    

    Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Heist and Seek

    2020 · 84 min★ 6.9

    Rated 6.9 with over 1,100 votes, an Aurora Teagarden mystery. A priceless Tudor crown vanishes during a Renaissance-themed library gala, and a security guard turns up dead, so librarian-sleuth Aurora (Candace Cameron Bure) investigates. The autumn library-fundraiser setting is cozy, and there is a proposal in the mix. A whodunit rather than a fall romance, so set expectations on the genre. Spoiler-free by design. Comfortable and brisk for cozy-crime regulars.

22. 22
    

    Dating the Delaneys

    2022 · 84 min★ 6.9

    Rated 6.9 with over 1,000 votes. Maggie (Rachel Boston), a divorced bakery owner, decides to re-enter dating after her mother finds a boyfriend and her ex gets engaged, and recruits a fellow parent (Paul Campbell) for low-stakes "practice dates." Her dating handle "Cool Mom MD" gets her mistaken for a doctor. The three-generations-of-Delaney-women angle and a national baking-show subplot keep it light. A warm second-chances romance, autumn-set rather than fall-themed.

23. 23
    

    Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Reunited and It Feels So Deadly

    2020 · 84 min★ 6.9

    Rated 6.9 with over 1,000 votes, an Aurora Teagarden mystery. Aurora (Candace Cameron Bure) attends her 20-year high school reunion, and the former prom king turns up dead in the hotel pool, pulling her into a web of old rivalries and blackmail. Niall Matter plays her fiance Nick. The reunion setting gives it a nostalgic kick. A cozy whodunit, not a fall romance, and I will leave the killer to you. Comfortable and familiar for Teagarden fans.

24. 24
    

    Chronicle Mysteries: Helped to Death

    2021 · 86 min★ 6.9

    Rated 6.9 with over 500 votes, a Chronicle mysteries entry. Podcaster Alex (Alison Sweeney) and editor Drew (Benjamin Ayres) go undercover at a self-help "rebirth" retreat run by a coach with a homicide conviction, then a guest dies on a hike. Blue moth-fungus supplements and vision boards used to crack a case keep it odd. A cozy investigative thriller rather than a fall romance. Spoiler-free here. A decent pick if you like wellness-world skewering with your mystery.

25. 25
    

    Love at the Thanksgiving Day Parade

    2012 · 84 min★ 6.8

    Rated 6.8 with over 2,200 votes, and a true Thanksgiving title in the fall overlap. Emily (Autumn Reeser) coordinates Chicago's Thanksgiving Day parade and clashes with a cynical consultant (Antonio Cupo) hired to judge its profitability. A marine-biologist boyfriend who wrote a book titled "Whales: What Are They Good For?" and a climactic confession on a moving float while dressed as Santa supply the comedy. A warm, festive parade romance. Genuinely seasonal, and easy to like.

26. 26
    

    Roadhouse Romance

    2021 · 84 min★ 6.8

    Rated 6.8 with over 1,500 votes. Callie (Lauren Alaina), an Army vet and physical therapist, comes home to find the family roadhouse struggling and her grandfather's secret BBQ-sauce recipe lost, then a stranded Hollywood director (Tyler Hynes) turns up. The annual Fall Festival anchors the season, and Hynes is reliably charming. A sci-fi action figure becomes a key auction item, which is its own delight. A warm save-the-restaurant romance. Solidly fall-flavored and very watchable.

27. 27
    

    Garage Sale Mystery: Murder by Text

    2017 · 83 min★ 6.8

    Rated 6.8 with over 900 votes, a Garage Sale Mystery. Antique-shop sleuth Jennifer (Lori Loughlin) suspects a country bass player's apparent suicide was staged, and follows a taser-tag clue and inconsistent floor scratches toward a beloved star who may be a killer. The cozy-meets-forensic detail is a fun wrinkle. A whodunit, not a fall romance, so come for the case and not a meet-cute. Spoiler-free here. Comfortable cozy-crime for Loughlin fans.

28. 28
    

    Chronicle Mysteries: The Wrong Man

    2019 · 120 min★ 6.8

    Rated 6.8 with over 900 votes, a Chronicle mysteries entry. The body of a woman missing three years turns up, and her acquitted-but-suspected husband asks podcaster Alex (Alison Sweeney) for help, while a colleague chases a shady river-shipping angle. Benjamin Ayres co-stars. At two hours, it is one of the more involved cases in the series. A cozy investigative mystery rather than a fall romance, set in autumn. Spoiler-free by design. Steady and watchable for the genre's fans.

29. 29
    

    Chronicle Mysteries: Vines That Bind

    2019 · 90 min★ 6.8

    Rated 6.8 with over 900 votes, a Chronicle mysteries outing set at a vineyard. Alex (Alison Sweeney) investigates a year-old "accidental" carbon-dioxide death of a winery founder, and things turn deadly when a secret will surfaces. A beard-off competition and Tina the Llama, a local celebrity animal the newsroom obsesses over, keep the tone light. The autumn vineyard setting is a plus. A cozy whodunit, not a romance. Spoiler-free here. Pleasant for cozy-crime regulars.

30. 30
    

    Field Day

    2023 · 84 min★ 6.8

    Rated 6.8 with over 700 votes. Recently widowed Jen (Rachel Boston) moves to her late husband's hometown and gets roped into the school's chaotic Field Day committee alongside two other outsider moms, finding a second chance with the PE teacher (Benjamin Ayres). The "breakfast pants" shame running gag and a custodian who will not shut off the sprinklers add comedy. A warm, slightly bittersweet romance about starting over. Autumn-set and gentle, with a real community-and-grief core.