HallmarkDB
    MoviesPeopleGuidesChatWatch Talking Hallmark on YouTube
    1. Home
    2. People
    3. Keith Martin Gordey
    Keith Martin Gordey headshot

    Keith Martin Gordey

    Actor·Active 2000–2023
    View on IMDbView on TMDB

    Career at a glance

    7Hallmark films

    2 at Christmas

    Audience rating6.4 / 10

    across 7 rated films

    Weirdness4.0 / 10

    Mostly standard issue

    Best reviewed

    Mystery on Mistletoe Lane7.0

    Keith Martin Gordey is the kind of actor you recognize before you can place him, the dependable supporting face who fills out a small town rather than headlines it. Across seven films from 2000 to 2023 he has never been the lead, and that suits the work he does. His ceiling is Mystery on Mistletoe Lane from 2023 at 7.0, just ahead of the gentle A Storm in Summer back in 2000 at 6.9 and Christmas in Evergreen at 6.6. He keeps it grounded, the weirdness numbers stay low, and there is no signature partner to point to. He turns up, plays it honest, and lets the leads have their moment. If you watch enough of these, you have already seen him do steady, unshowy work in the background.

    Keith’s signature

    Across 7 films, Keith frequently leans into Christmas, frequently plays an event planner and is almost always set in small towns.

    • Christmas2 films
    • small towns5 films
    • an event planner2 films
    • a return home3 films
    • enemies-to-lovers3 films
    • second-chance romance2 films

    8/10

    Keith's wildest Hallmark outing scores 8 out of 10 on the weirdness scale.

    Christmas in Evergreen, proof the formula can get strange.

    Known for

    How to Fall in Love poster
    How to Fall in Love6.4

    as Malcolm · 2012

    Weirdness 2/10

    Certified weirdChristmas in Evergreen poster
    Christmas in Evergreen6.6

    as Nick · 2017

    Weirdness 8/10

    Mystery on Mistletoe Lane poster
    Mystery on Mistletoe Lane7.0

    as Harold · 2023

    Weirdness 2/10

    You're Bacon Me Crazy poster
    You're Bacon Me Crazy6.5

    as Joe · 2020

    Weirdness 4/10

    Love, Once and Always poster
    Love, Once and Always6.2

    as Marcus · 2018

    Weirdness 5/10

    For Better or for Worse poster
    For Better or for Worse5.2

    as Ray · 2014

    Weirdness 4/10

    On-screen partners

    Barbara Tyson headshot
    Frequent co-star

    Keith’s most frequent on-screen partner is Barbara Tyson, with 2 films together.

    • You're Bacon Me Crazy (2020)·
    • How to Fall in Love (2012)

    Where Keith fits in

    The corners of the Hallmark universe Keith keeps turning up in. Each one is a full ranked guide.

    • 🧁Baking & cooking movies
    • 🏘️Small-town movies
    • 💢Enemies to lovers
    • 🔄Second-chance romance

    All 7 movies

    Newest first

    2020s

    2 films
    • 2023Mystery on Mistletoe LaneActor as Harold · Christmas7.0Weird 2/10
    • 2020You're Bacon Me CrazyActor as Joe · Big City6.5Weird 4/10

    2010s

    4 films
    • 2018Love, Once and AlwaysActor as Marcus · Royal/Estate6.2Weird 5/10
    • 2017Christmas in EvergreenActor as Nick · Christmas6.6Weird 8/10
    • 2014For Better or for WorseActor as Ray · Small Town5.2Weird 4/10
    • 2012How to Fall in LoveActor as Malcolm · Small Town6.4Weird 2/10

    2000s

    1 film
    • 2000A Storm in SummerActor as Cop · Small Town6.9Weird 3/10

    Keith’s standouts

    • Mystery on Mistletoe Lane poster
      Highest ratedMystery on Mistletoe Lane (2023)

      Best-reviewed of the 7, at 7.0/10

      7.0
    • For Better or for Worse poster
      Most divisiveFor Better or for Worse (2014)

      Lowest-rated of the 7 — every filmography has one

      5.2
    • Christmas in Evergreen poster
      WeirdestChristmas in Evergreen (2017)

      The strangest of the bunch — 8/10 on our weirdness scale

      6.6

    In pictures

    A quick look at Keith’s Hallmark run — headshot and the posters fans know best.

    • Keith Martin Gordey headshotKeith Martin Gordey
    • Mystery on Mistletoe Lane poster
    • You're Bacon Me Crazy poster
    • Love, Once and Always poster
    • Christmas in Evergreen poster
    • For Better or for Worse poster
    • How to Fall in Love poster
    • A Storm in Summer poster

    Keith’s creative circle

    Most directed by

    • Allan Harmon3 films

    Movies by year

    Keith Martin Gordey Hallmark movies by release year120001111112023

    Ratings profile

    Average 6.4 across 7 rated movies — each dot is one film.

    Rating distribution for this filmography1510mean 6.4For Better or for Worse: 5.2Love, Once and Always: 6.2How to Fall in Love: 6.4You're Bacon Me Crazy: 6.5Christmas in Evergreen: 6.6A Storm in Summer: 6.9Mystery on Mistletoe Lane: 7.0

    People also ask

    How many Hallmark movies has Keith Martin Gordey been in?
    We have 7 Hallmark movies on file for Keith Martin Gordey, spanning 2000–2023.
    What kind of Hallmark movies is Keith Martin Gordey known for?
    Keith is best known for Christmas movies and romances set in small towns, often with a return home.
    What is Keith Martin Gordey's highest-rated Hallmark movie?
    Mystery on Mistletoe Lane (2023) is Keith's best-reviewed Hallmark film, with a 7.0/10 audience rating.
    What is Keith Martin Gordey's most popular Hallmark movie?
    How to Fall in Love (2012) has more audience votes than any other Keith Martin Gordey Hallmark film, so it's the one most people have actually seen.
    Who does Keith Martin Gordey usually star with?
    Keith has shared 2 films with Barbara Tyson, their most frequent Hallmark co-star.
    Is Keith Martin Gordey still making Hallmark movies?
    The newest Keith Hallmark credit we have is from 2023; nothing later has turned up yet.
    How many Hallmark Christmas movies has Keith Martin Gordey made?
    Keith Martin Gordey turns up in 2 Hallmark Christmas movies.
    What was Keith Martin Gordey's first Hallmark movie?
    The earliest Keith Hallmark title we have is A Storm in Summer (2000).
    What does Keith Martin Gordey do in Hallmark movies?
    Keith Martin Gordey works on Hallmark films as actor.

    Data & sources

    Keith’s filmography, credits and ratings are compiled from IMDb and TMDB, then checked and tidied by the Talking Hallmark team. Last updated June 2026.

    Catalogue curated by Alanna of Talking Hallmark. About the project

    Talking Hallmark

    Love talking about these as much as watching them?

    So do we. Come hang out on the Talking Hallmark channel, where we dig into movies just like this one, episode after episode.

    Watch the latest episode
    I watched Hallmark’s WORST Christmas movie (so you don’t have to)

    “I watched Hallmark’s WORST Christmas movie (so you don’t have to)”

    HallmarkDB

    The complete Hallmark movie database. Built to surface the unusual ones, as the research desk for the Talking Hallmark YouTube channel.

    Curated by Alanna of Talking Hallmark.

    Explore

    • Movies
    • People
    • Database
    • Guides
    • Chat
    • About

    Browse

    • Christmas Movies
    • Most Unusual
    • Hidden Gems
    • Royal Romance
    • Time Travel
    • Small Town Stories

    Talking Hallmark

    • Watch on YouTube
    • Christmas Guide
    • Unusual Movies Guide
    © 2026 HallmarkDBAn independent fan project, not affiliated with Hallmark Media.