True Justice
Casey and her fellow law students investigate the evidence needed to clear an accused person.
2 films · 2024–2026 · Mystery
Start with the first filmMovies in viewing order
Watch Family Ties first, then Eye for an Eye. Casey's family supplies the reason for the opening investigation, making it the best introduction to the student team before they take on the second case.
Your viewing checklist
Saved films and watched progress stay separate in this browser.- 01
Film 1 · 2024
True Justice: Family Ties
Film source · Premiered 12 January 2024Casey and her law-school friends investigate the murder for which her brother is accused. The family connection introduces the team through a case where belief in someone's innocence has to become proof.
- 02
Film 2 · 2026
True Justice: Eye for An Eye
Film source · Premiered 23 May 2026The team helps a mother accused of killing another member of the Parent School Coalition. Their second case carries the exoneration premise into a school-parent community beyond Casey's own family.
About the series
True Justice begins with Casey trying to prove her brother innocent of murder. She and her law-school friends must find the killer to make that possible. Katherine McNamara leads the group, with Markian Tarasiuk, Nikki DeLoach and Benjamin Ayres among the cast. The follow-up gives the team another accused person to help. Choose this series if you want the investigation to begin with a challenge to the case against a suspect.
What to expect
The question is how to clear someone who already faces an accusation. That gives the investigation a different starting point from a sleuth happening upon a body. The students must move beyond believing their subject innocent and find evidence that identifies who committed the crime. Their group effort is the thread between the films.
The people who bring it to life
Casey Barlowe
The law student whose effort to clear her brother brings the team together.
More cast and guest appearances 18
- Marisa McIntyre2 films
Sarah Sharpe
- Alexander Nunez2 films
Liam Anderson
- Sabrina Saudin2 films
PJ Ellis
- Nikki DeLoach2 films
Professor Ambrose
- Benjamin Ayres2 films
D.A. Quinn, District Attorney Quinn
- Sam Ashe Arnold2 films
Marcus Barlowe, Marcus
- Carrie Schiffler1 film
Kimber
- Gabriel Burrafato1 film
Kenneth Randolph
- Jennifer De Lucia1 film
Olivia Flint
- Rick Hastings1 film
Kurt Teller
- Monica Rodriguez Knox1 film
Katherine Harris
- Sarah Murphy-Dyson1 film
Rachel Teller
- Jinny Wong1 film
Cherelle Anderson
- Krista Marchand1 film
Sharon
- 1 film
- Amanda Barker1 film
Cecilia Sands
- Matt Cassidy1 film
Austin
- Russell Yuen1 film
Principal Adams
Inside the series
The suspect is the starting point
Both films centre on clearing an accused person. Follow the evidence the team needs to challenge an existing case, rather than only counting possible killers.
The team moves beyond Casey's family
Family Ties begins with her brother. Eye for an Eye gives the students a new person to defend and a different community to investigate.
What to watch next
A few more answers
Which True Justice series is this?
This guide covers Hallmark's films beginning with True Justice: Family Ties, led by Katherine McNamara. Use that full title when searching for the first film.
Do I need a law background?
No. The films introduce the accusation and the team's investigation. The central task is finding evidence that clears the person they are helping.
Is a third film included?
No. This released-film guide includes Family Ties and Eye for an Eye. Unconfirmed future titles are not part of the sequence.
Sources & guide notes
Sources checked 13 September 2026. The film count follows the sequence above. Viewing options depend on your country.
Premiere date notes
True Justice: Family Ties. Official original airdate January 12, 2024.
True Justice: Eye for An Eye. Official original airdate May 23, 2026, direct page says Streaming Now.