Aimee Teegarden

When Hallmark hands Aimee Teegarden a script, she gets the top line. All six of her films since 2021 have her as the lead, no warming up in the background first. The holidays take half her slate, three of the six, though she splits the rest evenly and keeps things grounded rather than strange. Two of her films trade the small town for a big city, which makes her a touch less snowbound than the usual leading lady. Her standout is My Christmas Family Tree from 2021, a 7.6 that sits well above her others, with A New Year's Resolution close behind at 6.7. She has no steady co-star to lean on, so she carries each picture on her own.